Music and Vision homepage Jenna Orkin: Writer Wannabe Seeks Brush With Death - From the heights of greatness (the Juilliard School; musicians Rosalyn Tureck and Nadia Boulanger) via way-ward paths to the depths of wickedness these reminiscences will entertain and enlighten.


<<  -- 4 --  Roderic Dunnett    Cosseted by Robespierre


Scarpia gets his chance in Act II (Read's rouged fireside lighting of the huge room is even more of a triumph). Offstage flute and soft strings create an artifically lulling mood; for Scarpia is in full plotting vein -- outwardly proccupied with Cavaradossi, but inwardly fixated on Tosca. Yet even her seduction (for which Cavaradossi is equally a tool to be disposed of) is to be only en passant : 'Once I conceive a pleasure, I satisfy it, and discard it.' Leiferkus's exchanges with his agent and confidant, Spoletta (the seasoned Robin Leggate) were consistently and aptly unpleasant. The obscene little juridical procession which precedes the torturing of Cavaradossi is staged with a gleeful nastiness (how terrifying those words 'it is a loyal subject who accuses you' are : grim shades of Madame Defarge).

The start of the scene is all the more effective for Leiferkus and Pavarotti singing restrainedly, enabling the sounds of Tosca's cantata to penetrate from offstage. With López-Cobos nursing tenderly, there were lots of wonderful little orchestral details : the cello sigh that precedes 'Where is Angelotti?' Low flute (again) for the tense Tosca-Cavaradossi exchange; oboe, clarinet and bass clarinet as sounds of the torture emerge; the little march into which the orchestra breaks at Cavaradossi's Marengo outburst 'Victoria, victoria'; and dark paired flutes -- again shades of Pelléas -- for Scarpia's outrageous proposal : 'It will be for some other payment' ('Già mi dicon venal').

Carol Vaness (Tosca) and Sergei Leiferkus (Scarpia) in the 2002 Covent Garden production of 'Tosca'. Photo © Bill Cooper

Puccini's balancing of Act II, so subtly phased and graded, is too astonishingly good to retail. But so too was Leiferkus's, right down to the little visual Leitmotif of removing, and returning, Tosca's shawl. The act builds inexorably to its centrepiece, Tosca's great aria 'Vissi d'arte', awesomely prefaced by side drum, bassoon, brass, then paired clarinets, and superbly delivered, with affectionate attendant strings, from rear stage by Vaness. López-Cobos might have kept the string lament even softer (like the wonderful pianissimo double bass pizzicato with which it concluded, or the admirable quadruple piano achieved for Tosca and Cavaradossi, so advantageous to the building drama of Act III). Puccini's plaint is of extraordinary provenance -- the chords are in places identical with Hungarian courtly 'recruiting' music.

Continue >>

Copyright © 17 January 2002 Roderic Dunnett, Coventry, UK





 << Music & Vision home           Russian UK premières >>