Widening the scope
TREVOR HOLD discusses John Ireland's songs in the light of a new recording
To listen to the aural illustrations in this review, you may need to download
RealNetworks' realplayer G2.
John Ireland (1879-1962) is one of the major English Romantic song-composers,
yet compared with Quilter, Warlock, Gurney and Finzi, he is frequently neglected
by both recitalists and listeners: unaccountably so, for his songs range
from the light and popular to the darkly sombre and potentially cater for
a wide range of tastes. As in all his music, there is a strong autobiographical
element in his solo songs, which act almost as a musical diary of his feelings.
Hence we have recurrent phrases and ideas which echo from song to song when
similar emotional situations occur. His setting of Dante Gabriel Rossetti's
'The one hope' is probably the most extreme example, being virtually an
anthology of his songwriting techniques, yet for all that marvellously compact
and subtle. It may well be that this intimacy, the very private nature of
his songs, disturbs some listeners, who prefer something less subjective
in their music - unless of course the composer is Mahler......
This recording, however, should satisfy even the most timid. Of the
composer's 90 or so songs, nearly 70 are included here; the only major omissions
are The Land of Lost Content and Marigold, which are represented
by a token song from each ('Ladslove' and 'Spleen'). It includes one rarity,
the Dowson setting, 'When I am old', dating from the 1920s but the manuscript
of which has only recently come to light; this is the first-ever recording.
The songs span 35 years of Ireland's career, from Songs of a Wayfarer
(1903-5) to Five XVI Century Poems (1938), and range from the
money-spinning ballads 'Sea Fever' and 'Great things' to the songcycles
We'll to the woods no more (1927-8) and Five Poems by Thomas Hardy
(1926). The latter is one of the sombre masterpieces 20th-century
English song and could be by no-one but Ireland. One can do no more
than marvel at the ease with which he sets Hardy's none-too-easy-to-set
words. There is a masterly balance between vocal-line and accompaniment,
neither dominating the other. Maltman and Johnson's performances are at
their best here. (click to listen.) Equally
fine is Lisa Milne's performance of 'Her song', from Ireland's other Hardy
'cycle, Three Songs to Poems by Thomas Hardy (1925). It shows Ireland's
skill with the strophic song, particularly the way he adapts his music from
verse (click to listen) to verse (click
Ireland's importance as a songwriter lies not only in the quality of
his individual songs, but also in his attempt to widen the scope of English
song. This is evident in the wide range of contemporary poetry that he set,
including, as well as Hardy and Housman, Arthur Symons and John Masefield,
and taking in such unexpected names as Sylvia Townshend Warner and Aldous
Huxley, both of whom are better known as novelists than poets. Ireland's
setting of Huxley's early poem 'The trellis' is one of his most satisfying
achievements, and John Mark Ainsley's performance captures the drowsiness
of a hot summer day perfectly. (click to listen.)
Another way that Ireland expanded the scope of English song was in his
rethinking of the role of voice and piano. Earth's Call (1918) -
subtitled 'A Sylvan Rhapsody' - goes beyond the bounds of the traditional
solo song, with the piano having long solo interludes; the 14-lines of Harold
Monro's sonnet are given a spacious five-minute setting. It is indeed a
tiny operatic scena and looks forward to the solo cantatas and canticles
of Tippett and Britten. Equally unusual is his second Houseman 'cycle, We'll
to the woods no more, which consists of two song settings followed by
an epilogue, 'Spring will not wait', for piano alone.
The singing throughout is superb - Maltman is in particularly good form
- whilst Graham Johnson's accompaniments are, as ever, beyond praise. My
only quibble is that some of the songs are placed rather randomly. Why,
for example, is 'Tryst' separated from its companion, 'During music'? They
were intended by Ireland to be a diptych. And why include just 'Ladslove'
from The Land of Lost Content? As with any song in a songcycle, it
loses its impact when taken out of context.
Lest the impression be given that John Ireland's songs are all doom,
gloom and 'lost content', let us end with the composer in lighter vein.
One of his most attractive works is his last song-book, Five XVIth Century
Poems, where Warlock-like, he casts his net amongst the shoals of Elizabethan
lyrics. 'An aside' is a rare but welcome example of Ireland's impish humour.
(click to listen.)
Copyright © Trevor Hold, August
<< Music &
Vision homepage More CD reviews >>
The Songs of JOHN IRELAND
Lisa Milne, soprano
John Mark Ainsley, tenor
Christopher Maltman, baritone
Graham Johnson, piano
CDA 67261/2 (2 CDs) DDD
Copyright © 1999 Hyperion Records Ltd.
Recorded in association with the John Ireland Trust
ORDER THIS CD FROM CROTCHET