<< -- 2 -- David Wilkins Mr Valiant-for-Truth
From the very opening the micro-qualities are apparent: the weight of
the lower strings, the concentration of the woodwind, the glory of the brass.
Wand allows no place for self-conscious over-emoting. (Many years ago I
attended a Zubin Mehta Los Angeles Philharmonic Proms performance that overwhelmed
at the time but could hardly recall a week later.) Service to the score
is everything and it's the gift of a lifetime's experience to
be able to assert such control [listen -- CD1 track
1, 6:25-7:18]. The climaxes are, as expected, shattering in sonorous
terms but always retain their vital importance in the overall architecture.
Tenutos and silences are as important and are given their full measure.
The recording, made at live performances in the Berlin Philharmonie, is
amply clear and reverberant without needing any added cod-Cathedral acoustic.
Karajan once pointed out that, 'perhaps you have to go to the church at
St Florian's to understand why his music is as it is, with so many
pauses and such great spaciousness.' Well -- that's a thought,
but Pierre Boulez' recent Vienna Philharmonic performance recorded
in St Florian's -- as wonderful as it is in many surprising ways --
seems hindered rather than enhanced by an acoustic that, inevitably, fudges
some of the detail.
Wand takes the Scherzo at a steady pace -- less immediately exciting
than some, perhaps -- that better allows him to exploit the music's
fluidity. The vigour is generated from within the body of sound (a feat
that, recalling Szell, he also works so magically in Beethoven and, supremely,
Schubert's 9th) rather than glossily imposed [listen
-- CD1 track 2, 4:33-5:35]. In the Trio section, the contradictions of
Bruckner's nature -- rustic and naïve but also charming and
sophisticated are captured in playing that often has the delicacy of a Brahms
Copyright © 24 February 2002
David Wilkins, Eastbourne, Sussex, UK
CD INFORMATION - BMG CLASSICS 74321 82866 2
PURCHASE THIS DISC FROM CROTCHET
& Vision home Recent reviews
English Hymnal >>