<< -- 3 -- Robert Anderson EDITOR'S CHOICE?
In between much that is hectic in the manner of President Bush's desire to
take himself to Mars (as soon as possible, please), there is the occasional moment
of repose, as when in the Adagio of No 1 Schumann affectionately recalls the slow
movement of Beethoven's Ninth
[listen -- track 3, 0:00-1:34].
The most original movement is the 'Scherzo' of No 3, which Schumann casts as
a subtle set of variations. The team does not have the measure of its wayward
charm. Clara was right that here in fact was something 'new'. The Zehetmair
players divert attention from the novelty by an occasional roughness that is
quite out of character. These two variations show them at their worst and their best
[listen -- track 6, 1:25-2:33].
Copyright © 11 February 2004
Robert Anderson, London UK
BUY THIS DISC ONLINE
Zehetmair Quartett - Robert Schumann
472 169-2 Stereo NEW RELEASE 49'32" 2003 ECM Records GmbH
The Zehetmair Quartett: Thomas Zehetmair, violin; Matthias Metzger, violin; Ruth Killius, viola; Françoise Groben, cello
Robert Schumann: String Quartet No 1 in A minor Op 41 No 1; String Quartet No 3 in A Op 41 No 3