Music and Vision homepage Natalie Artemas-Polak - classical CD and book reviews, liner and programme notes, articles and lectures: CLICK TO CONTACT

CD Spotlight

Tender Warmth

Beethoven cello sonatas -
heard by
ROBERT ANDERSON

'Starker's interpretation suggests he has not quite grasped the magnitude of his responsibility.'

Beethoven: Complete Works for Cello and Piano. Janos Starker, Rudolf Buchbinder. © 2009 Warner Classics and Jazz

On this recording of more than thirty years back it is, perhaps surprisingly, the three sets of variations that fare best, and particularly the pair on themes from Beethoven's favourite Magic Flute. Both tunes, 'Bei Männern' and 'Ein Mädchen', involve Papageno, and Beethoven can afford to be playful, rather more so than in the comparatively portentous Handelian 'See the conqu'ring hero'. There is some heartbreak, too, because Pamina is also involved in the first set, and poor Papageno considers he gets a very rough deal throughout at the hands of Sarastro.In the sonatas Starker is never less than neat and competent, but he has too little in reserve to express the more eloquent of Beethoven's phrases, and cannot quite withstand the full power of Buchbinder's keyboard, which bears little relation, after all, to Beethoven's...

Copyright © 3 July 2012 Robert Anderson,
London UK

-------

BEETHOVEN: COMPLETE WORKS FOR CELLO AND PIANO

LUDWIG VAN BEETHOVEN

WARNER CLASSICS

CELLO MUSIC

PIANO MUSIC

 << Music & Vision home      Recent CD reviews       Elena Kuschnerova >>

 

Wild Camel Protection Foundation - Patron: Dr Jane Goodall CBE